-
March 2024 by Jomarcia Franck
not very goid pizza
-
March 2024 by Mandy Chardoul
The owner(s) should know that as customers drive up to walk in to place an order (as we did tonight at 6:30pm - they close at 7pm) other customers, with pizzas in hand, are warning them not to bother. We had two separate groups stop us - almost like a community service announcement- to save us the frustration of trying to order a pizza. So sad that the management is dismissing reviews, like it’s the customers fault. Complete lack of awareness. We are here to support Captiva’s rebuild but certain business owners are making it harder than it needs to be. We are heading to Sanibel for dinner.
-
March 2024 by Jason Valdes
I never write bad reviews but this place deserves one… same thing as previous customer reviews state. First of, it was a washout so we tried ordering pizza for the kids since there was a bad storm. No one picked up our calls for over 45 mins. When I finally decided to go in person to order, I was confronted by a really rude man who then ignored me and told me they were closed. It was 6:45pm and the restaurant closes at 8pm. Don’t like to play the card but I felt like I was treated unfairly and very poorly. Customers beware.
-
March 2024 by Drew Barnhart
I don’t leave reviews often so take note of this. Walked in and got the worst service humanly possible from one man behind the counter. I understand not being able to serve us due to busyness, however the treatment we received was sarcastic and rude and his facial expressions were the most unwelcoming I’ve experienced anywhere in my life. At no point were we rude, we simply asked if we could order inside and received the worst service, even after trying to call ahead (phone number did not work). We asked if there was another way to order ahead to which we were answered with “as you can see we’re super busy.” No one can tell if you’re busy, no one was in the store and there was no way of seeing actual “busyness.” Wish I could review the food itself which I’m certain is great, but the service was terrible.
-
March 2024 by Dave Kneisel
Friendly hardworking staff. Food is great! Highly recommend.
-
January 2024 by Jake Raisanen
Absolutely horrible customer service, the one dude that was there wouldn’t take out his ear buds to take my order.
-
January 2024 by Traveling O
We ordered Pizza via phone from Captiva Island Pizza--16" Cheese, 16" pepperoni. It was outstanding. One of best pepperoni pizzas I've had. Juicy, perfect dough.Captiva Island Pizza had it ready for pickup exactly when specified. Highly recommend.
-
November 2023 by Yasmine Mobley
My friend and I ordered a mushrooms and pepperoni pizza. It was delicious!Vegetarian options: They have all the veggies you could need.
-
November 2023 by Chris Thomann
Great pizza, friendly staff. Very nice shop. I can only recommend.
-
November 2023 by Marc Thomann
Best pizza in Sanibel Island!!Small 1 man operation. :-)
-
October 2023 by jfehn
Great pizza, great service. Salad was large enough for two. Pizza was well-cooked with ample toppings. I highly recommend Captiva Island Pizza!
-
October 2023 by Music Playlist
Amazing pizza and friendliest staff so hardworking! Great atmosphere and art and place! Thank you!
-
October 2023 by Evelio Gonzalez
Great pizza !!!
-
August 2023 by Giovanni C
Pizza and cheesy bread were good.
-
August 2023 by Brenda Wildes
We ordered take out. 2 large pizzas and cheese bread.
