Capt Anthony's Seafood Market is known for offering the freshest and most delicious seafood on the West Coast, including red snapper, grouper, stone crab, and mullet. Unlike other commercial fishermen who stay on their boats for two weeks, Capt Anthony is a day boat fisherman who catches fresh fish daily, ensuring high quality and tenderness. Customers often praise the stone crab, especially the homemade mustard sauce, and enjoy bringing home the fresh fish to cook themselves. The market has weathered storms and challenges, but remains committed to providing excellent seafood. Despite setbacks like storm damage, they continue to take orders by text and operate their small market. Visitors also appreciate the casual, authentic experience and the chance to enjoy fresh seafood and hot dogs at the market. Many customers from far away, including New York, make special trips to get their seafood fix at Capt Anthony’s. Overall, the market is a beloved spot for fresh fish, stone crabs, and a true seafood experience on Anna Maria Island.
Been coming to Captain Anthony’s for 10/15 years………always the highest quality fresh seafood and……..my favorite…….stone crabs……..today they even opened up on their day off to hook my family up with some claws……..the absolute best seafood in AMI
February 2025
THE FRESHEST AND MOST DELICIOUS STONE CRAB ON THE WEST COAST! Don’t forget the homemade mustard sauce. Also purchased fresh red snapper to cook at home. Incredibly fresh and tender! We came all the way from Buffalo for this! Go Bills!
February 2025
Just got here from Upstate NY. Best seafood ever. They got hit hard but are working hard to get back running. Please support them!
