-
December 2023 by Andrew Giannettino
Most of the staff is friendly and courteous. However the owner has always been exceedingly rude to me. I’ve shopped there and at his previous store for YEARS. I’ve spent THOUSANDS of dollars there (just in 2022 alone). So I can accurately say that this store OVERCHARGES for product. I would go in there every day to see if the TCG singles had been updated which they usually weren’t. And I knew full well I could get new product cheaper at either Walmart next door or any other game store, yet I still spent my money here supporting small business. I didn’t want it to come to this but I am no longer interested in supporting this business. Not after the way I’ve been spoken to.
-
December 2023 by macmakeupguru07
If you’re in need of anything gaming, Pokemon, collectible, etc. this is your place! Meredith is always incredibly kind and helpful. I first started shopping here when I needed a birthday present for my boyfriend who loves Pokémon. Not only was I able to find items my boyfriend doesn’t have (a somewhat difficult task since my bf is a big collector) but they answered every question I had and were very patient. Now it’s my go to place! Plus I would MUCH rather support a smaller business over a place like Amazon any day especially since Amazon’s Pokémon cards aren’t the most trustworthy anyway. Nutmeg for the win!
-
December 2023 by Lisa Johnson
I'm not versed well in the land of gaming but I had a major need for presents for some loved ones and Mere went above and beyond in helping me make sure I looked like the best aunt in the whole world. I owe you my life!!!
-
November 2023 by Kelsey Collins
I genuinely can't say enough about how wonderful of a store this is. From the selection of games, the events, to the incredible community that it fosters.My husband and I, as well as many of our family and friends have had nothing but good experiences over the past 2 years during our weekly hang outs.I highly recommend that you stop by!
-
November 2023 by Chris Lomedico
Great gaming spot for all ages
-
October 2023 by Matthew Magnifico
Ive been going to game stores for the past 25+ years. This is a great store. Theres a good community, lots of events, and knowledgeable staff. Prices are what you would expect from any game store. Highly recommend.
-
September 2023 by Jason Pickup
Lousy selection and they over charge for products. $33 for $20 paint cans, $40 for decks that sell from the manufacturer for $17. Shop elsewhere
-
August 2023 by Cassie Shepard
I have in fact been to your new store out of curiosity mainly. As usual you lie. I did not leave a written review out of an attempt to be civil and just left it at the very true way I rate this business. Which is in my right to do. I refuse to purchase anything as I have been told previously that my money was not welcome in a very rude manner so no thank you I will not be frequenting your establishment or supporting it and I will take the advice given at the time and go ahead and just purchase somewhere else.
-
May 2023 by Alex Venditti
One of my go tos for cards and games they're all pretty cool there very welcoming atmosphere
-
April 2023 by Kylo
Never had an issue with my friends and I gaming here. Lovely spot to hang and play some games
-
February 2023 by Cory Scott
A unique and fun experience that can only be found here. Worth the drive if you're out of the way. I'm roughly an hour away, and would happily make this trip at least once or twice a week, time allowing.
-
January 2023 by Tricia B.
I now have an answer to my personal haunting question - what went into the old Hallmark store in New Milford? The answer - Nutmeg Games, and there's something very fitting about that. They sell, it seems, every type of game you can play with friends. Card games, board games, those games with the little figurines you can paint. They even had people in the back playing the games! Check out their Event calendar online, it will show you what game nights are when. They also had other collectibles, most notably Squishables. As a personal testament to my self-restraint, I only left with two and one was a keychain. The cashier was friendly without being stalkerish - she let me browse at my own pace and come to her with questions. This seems like a great addition to New Milford for a pace to go, and meet up with friends.
-
January 2023 by Stephanie Greenhill
This is our favorite store in town! Great assortment of games, squishables, and cards. My husband also sells cards here often and it has always been a great experience.They’re very family friendly too! My toddler loves to come with us to the store and they’re always so sweet to her (even when she’s running around like crazy lol).Highly recommend!
-
January 2023 by Calvin Anvil
Friendly staff and welcoming players. There is a good mix of competitive and casual events, and a player base that creates an environment to match. No sharks or gotcha moments at regular weeklies, and larger comp events are run with competitive integrity in mind.Inventory is great for all types of tabletop players. D&D figures and books are plenty, boardgames shelves have a good variety, and card game supplies range from budget-friendly to top quality. Sealed product for cards games (more than just the big three) are plentiful, and singles for MTG, Pokemon, and Yugioh.
-
January 2023 by Cali Dibartolo
I've been going here since I started collecting again in like 2020ish? And by far this is the best place you can go for any gaming needs (especially pokemon) I buy and sell here and it's always been a great experience. Everyone of the staff members are awesome and I always feel welcomed when I'm there even with my 2 young kids! Definitely need to go there if your in this area!