Toy Stores near New Haven, CT

16 locations found near New Haven
View Map

“Heartbroken to see that this store is closing. It will leave a big hole in this block!The storefront is unassuming, but this store is amazing. I am so sorry for not stopping in long ago! This shop is well-stocked with everything you need to make art — from paints and canvas to popsicle sticks for craft projects with little ones: jewelry findings, magic markers, drawing pads, stickers, kits…If you can think of it, it is probably there. Also puzzles, games, gifts, and high-end greeting cards. A great place for stocking stuffers or last minute gifts! Friendly staff is ready to guide you to what you need or to leave you alone if you wish to browse. Prices are very reasonable. If you are anywhere near downtown New Haven you have to check this place out!”

4.8 Superb24 Reviews

“Just an amazing museum that happens to sell toys!Mark is truly a master of his craft and the attention to every customer is level of service you just dont see any more.”

5 Superb97 Reviews

“Such an incredible shop! The selection is large and I am grateful for the gift suggestions from the owner/staff when I am stumped on what to give. Thank you for wrapping! I love this place as it brings joy into shopping which is hard to do these days.”

4.9 Superb59 Reviews

“We needed birthday presents for a one year old. The store was well stocked with toys and other materials. Wendy was very informed and helpful. We'll be back”

4.9 Superb48 Reviews

“Great looking and clean store with a friendly staff. Has a lot of cool peices with something for everybody, definitely recommend it to anyone who wants to start a hobby”

4.8 Superb30 Reviews

“This Toy Life is great! One of my favorite local toy stores to go to! Bobby T is knowledgeable and friendly. Great selection of toys, and is always putting out new things, running sales, or events in store. Bobby creates a welcoming atmosphere at This Toy Life for the community to come and browse or take part in events that help build connections and share the love of games, toys, and other forms of media in all ages from child to adult. This place is a great place to bring your kids or to find that one item you’re missing in your collection, be sure to check this place out.”

4.8 Superb16 Reviews

“It's the best place to buy any card for any occasion.....and it also offers gift ideas, balloons, toys, jewelry, nicknack, purses, wind chimes, candles, candy. The list goes on and on.....”

4.6 Superb10 Reviews

“The Paper Store in Milford is one of the most beautifully organized and merchandised Hallmark stores in the area. Every display has a wide variety of clever, creative and unique items. I always love unusual funny quotes, and they have them tastefully displayed and decorated on mugs, plaques and decorative nic nacs. The staff is welcoming, friendly and helpful. There is plenty of parking in the Whole Foods shopping strip. The Paper Store is a great spot to get last minute gifts!”

4.4 Superb50 Reviews

“Great shop with large selection of gifts items, jewelry, clothing, cards, toys, candles. Love shopping here for unusual gifts for friends and family. Store is always clean and neat with friendly staff.”

4.4 Superb55 Reviews

“Excellent services overall and experience with all they offer. Especially old video games and old refurbished consoles and all that expertise. They offer dvd,Blu rays,CDs a pop vinyls and all pop culture stuff. A must see and buy for all ? nerds and non nerds!”

4.3 Superb37 Reviews

“If you need a gift at the last minute or obviously a greeting card this is the best place in Branford to go. While they don't have a lot of things anybody needs they have a lot of things that will do as a gift”

4.3 Superb44 Reviews

“Nice shop , t's been there for years, since 1996 I believe so they are definitely doing something right!They have the basics, comics, cards, gaming and also statues, action figures, and other stuff like shirts, etc.I don't do cards and games, so I won't say that much only that they have a good amount of both and it all looks recent so I would wager it's current and new stock..When I go I go for the funny books ( a term my Grandfather would use when I was a wee lad getting Richie Rich, Hot Stuff the devil and Hulk comics when I'd go with him to the grocery store.My son and I lean towards independent publishers, like Image, IDW, Boom, Aftershock and Avatar back when they had several horror and action comics like Crossed, Uber (definitely not ride share ) and titles those lines. We usually find you at like or just learned about and willing to try, but the selection on these books are a little light, but these are niche titles not everyone will like, and they are there to make money after all, and you will find all the popular Marvel and DC books with the famous heroes there and in good supply.I don't collect like I used to but I still like to look for something new to try every once in a while and I've never walked out empty handed or with buyers remorse trying a new title, and whether your looking your your DC or MCU favorites or something of the beaten path, you won't regret stopping by and checking the store out.”

4.3 Superb56 Reviews

“One of my all time favorite stores!! GREAT prices and so many options to choose from! they have everything from clothes to make up, to even Funko pops, arts and crafts, food, children's department.Every time I shop at five below, I always leave with more than 30 items and spend as low as 50 for everything. 1000/10 recommend :3”

4.1 Good23 Reviews

“love five below!funny story:came here one night to do some shopping for a friend and accidently locked my keys in the car, including my phone. had to go inside and ask t to use phone and the women there were so kind and let me call my dad and even wait for him inside since it was dark out and late.those women deserve a raise!! thank you for your kindness and for making me feel better!100000/10”

4.1 Good29 Reviews