McDonald Toyota in Greeley, part of the McDonald Automotive Group, has been serving Colorado since 1965. The dealership offers the complete line of Toyota models and access to over 500 quality, pre-owned vehicles. McDonald Toyota is committed to putting the customer first and giving back to the Northern Colorado community. The dealership is a proud community leader and partner, always looking for ways to collaborate and support local events, non-profits, businesses, and individuals. Customers have praised the friendly, professional, and genuinely helpful staff, including the used car sales manager, James Mayberry, who is described as hard-working, genuine, and caring. Customers who have worked with sales representatives like Orlando and Teddy have had positive experiences, with the staff being upfront, transparent, and never pushy. The financing process with Tom was also noted as easy to understand and clear. Overall, the buying experience at McDonald Toyota Greeley is described as smooth, transparent, and leaving customers feeling comfortable and confident with their purchase. The dealership has received excellent reviews for its service, with customers appreciating the low-pressure sales approach and the team's efforts to ensure their satisfaction. McDonald Toyota in Greeley is highly recommended by its customers for anyone in the market for a new or used vehicle.
I worked with James Mayberry, who is the used car sales manager. Great guy, awesome personality, and extremely helpful. The last thing you think of when working with James is used car sales manager stigma. Hard-working, genuine, and caring. Highly recommend.
October 2025
Nekoda made the entire process super easy. We were treated fairly, with kindness, and we couldn’t be more thrilled with our new Tundra. We’re pleased to be part of the McDonald Toyota family.
October 2025
The salesmen were very helpful! Very low pressure. The salesmen worked as a team with the sales manager to ensure I was satisfied. The paperwork went fairly smooth even after some work around that was needed.
