-
March 2024 by Alex Spencer
Great pizza. Super fresh ingredients and awesome
-
December 2023 by Veronica “Ronnie” Barrett
Went with a family of four and had pizzas, garlic bread sticks and cheese curds. Everything was very good. Looking forward to going again soon!!
-
November 2023 by Lisa G.
We were in town for a family event but always choose to get an AirBnb or Vrbo. This was our first time on Mill St. We looked here on Yelp for nearby pizza spots and realized this was a 3 min walk across the street. It's small inside and looks like it's small business/family owned, which we always support. There is a brick oven that immediately intrigued my husband. We ordered 10" pizzas for our teens to go and sat at the bar while we waited. My husband got a local IPA and I just asked for a red wine. The gal gave me a can of "red wine" that I was not expecting. I tried to drink the chilled red wine but I just couldn't. I do t know why I didn't say something when my husband mentioned he could see several bottles of wine they could've poured. I guess in the moment I didn't want to offend the gal's decision to take me so literally with the request for red wine because everyone there is so nice and friendly. We will choose the place we stayed at again and will definitely visit this restaurant again. I'll just be more clear on what I want to drink.
-
October 2023 by Ann Evans
This was the best pizza I have had since moving here (northern New Mexico). The dough, the sauce, the toppings were all spot on. It was cooked perfectly! I was so happy. The menu is great, and the atmosphere was adorable. The service was excellent as well.
-
October 2023 by Michelle McClure
The pizza was so good. We had a Supreme Wolverine. The service was great!
-
October 2023 by Kitty Clark
I'm crying right now because I live in Northern Nevada and cannot get a Eepa's pizza whenever I want one! Visited Bayfield in late September and had the best pizza ever!
-
September 2023 by Keith Wheeler
This is a great local pizza company. Locally sourced produce and meats. Limited hours of operation due to staffing issues. But well worth the effort. Try the Wolverine pizza and a portion benefits the local high school. Highly recommend!
-
August 2023 by Mike Showalter
I just want to say I love the pizza but the price has gone up, to be honest I won’t go back and eat there again. It isn’t worth the high prices, I mean $26 dollars just for a pizza and bread sticks is crazy, it’s only a 10in pizza, a month ago it was less then $20 for that. I can get more for my money at Aj’s pizza and it’s right down the street. Not worth the price at all to go back, sorry…
-
August 2023 by SuperVillain Obituary
This place is great. Best bang for your buck you'll find and easily the best pizzeria around. Great staff too!
-
July 2023 by Alex Davis
I’m staying at the outdoorsy rv park across the highway And was looking for something local and close to eat. I read the reviews of this place And thought I’d check it out as I haven’t had pizza in a while. What a pleasant surprise this place was! Great ambience, super friendly staff! I ordered the jalapeño poppers for an appetizer. They came out quick and were amazing and gooey and cheesy! Just the right amount of breading as to not overpower and let the flavors come through. A definite win! I also ordered the dangeroni pepperoni pizza. All the pizzas are 10” in size which makes for a perfect portion and a quick bake. It came out much sooner than a traditional oven baked pizza would. Absolutely fantastic! U can’t see it in the pics, but the cheese was stringy and gooey like in commercials. Yes, there was some char on the crust, but it wasn’t hard…rather crispy and soft at the same time if that makes sense! Definitely in my top 5 pizzas in Colorado! Glad I stopped by here for a final farewell before leaving the state for good. Highly recommend!
-
July 2023 by ColoradoKat343
We have eaten at Eepas a few times; I should have reviewed sooner than now, but its Fabulous! I'm to the point that I won't eat pizza because I've been so disappointed with most I've tried, but this is worth the 45 minute drive! Thin delicious crust with obviously high quality ingredients, and you can tell the food is made with pride. GO! They have really naughty appetizers (oh my gosh, the pizza egg rolls are great as are the cheese curds) and I love their Ceaser salad - perfect with the GREAT pizza! ENJOY! Bayfield is lucky to have Eepas!
-
July 2023 by Karen
Excellent pizza, great service. A must try.
-
July 2023 by Steph
We drive from Durango to Bayfield just for Eepa's delicious pizza..and their fresh tasting salads..and their yummy pizza eggrolls..everything that we've tried has been really good! Nice, friendly, prompt service and always greeted with a smile. We love Eepa's!!Kid-friendliness: Toys and high chairs ?Dietary restrictions: Gluten free pizza ?
-
June 2023 by Kevin Montoya
Hidden gem with a tiny dining room that is more than made up for with delicious food and friendly staff. We had the brick oven pizzas, cheese curds and garlic cheese bread, and I would recommend them all!
-
June 2023 by Brandon Eubanks
They will give you free food if you sing I'm a little tea cup in a soprano tone. They truly do respect the arts. Also, if you buy 100 pizzas you get one free. Ask for a punch card.
