-
December 2023 by Taylor Starr
Trying to figure out why the website says open and the door says they close at 8pm but it’s 6pm and all the lights are off and no one is
-
December 2023 by Salira Alice
Very delicious and very nice even when they were having technical issues. Definitely a place worth going.
-
September 2023 by C. T.
My all-time favorite place for ice cream. I strongly recommend their dark chocolate flavored ice cream, it is absolutely delicious. The staff is always friendly. Sometimes it’s nice to sit outside during a summer day and enjoy their ice cream.
-
August 2023 by Travis C.
My all-time favorite place for ice cream. I strongly recommend their dark chocolate flavored ice cream, it is absolutely delicious. The staff is always friendly. Sometimes it’s nice to sit outside during a summer day and enjoy their ice cream.
-
June 2023 by Charles Holt
We have been using Maggie Moo’s shop to order our Great American Cookies for years because they are usually better than the one you get at the mall. And it’s far easier to get in and out instead of walking into the mall. But today when I tried to order a cookie to pick up on Saturday I was told that I had to pay over the phone instead of when I pick it up. I’m sorry but I will not give out my credit card information over the phone. I guess we will stop ordering from them and go back to the mall.Update to responseWe have been ordering cakes from this place for around 8 years and I was only asked once to pre-pay in all this time. And that one time was during the height of COVID a few years ago. And in that instance I came by the store after ordering and paid in advance. I stress again it’s not right to request credit card information over the phone. But we have never been asked to pre-pay at any other time. The mall GAC will allow you to order and pay upon pickup. I called and asked them after I tried to order from here. I tried the on-line option but you can’t order the small round cookie cake. I thought about stopping by to pre-pay but I think we will just stop ordering from Maggie MO’s and go back to the mall. The decorations use to be really good from here but lately they haven’t been as good. I think the guy that use to the cakes left.
-
June 2023 by Global Comm
The store needs a little cleaning as it is a bit dirty. The walnuts in the ice cream we ordered were stale, and the outside patio needed a good power washing. I will not give a store front a good review just the there product was good. There are plenty of things that we look at, and a clean place is a must. This is surely a management issue. Please clean and update your topings.
-
April 2023 by sunaina reddy
I would give a negative rating if possible. Their brownie fudge ice cream was very bad.. whole fudge was sticking to the cup and all the fudge was very hard. Brownie bites were not fresh. Brownie bites and fudge was very hard and they formed a big lump together. That happens only when the quality is poor. Waffles were not cooked properly. When I asked the service person if I could get a replacement as the ice cream was not good, they were very rude. Overall it was a very bad experience. Bad management and very bad service.
-
April 2023 by Harsha Maddula
Not a great place to visit. Tastes bad and worst service and management. Don’t get cheated by the pics added
-
January 2023 by Matthew Richardson
Ice cream was good, we just came in about 30 minute before closing time and staff seemed VERY unhappy to see us
-
December 2022 by RobinW JustMeAllDayEveryDay
American Cookie Company! I stopped here to get some mini double doozie cookies! (Cookie company is inside the same business with the icecream.) Nice place, easy to get to- (much easier than having to trek thru the mall, just for a cookie!) You can sit inside or just stop by for a quick treat! Ready made cookies- plus ice cream with choices & toppings!Clean quiet- plenty of parking
-
October 2022 by Amanda Hoskins
So thankful for our local Maggie Moos/ Great American Cookie and the way that they give back to our community and to the Fayetteville school system! They go above and beyond to ensure that our kiddos are well fed before the games and their willingness to give is so appreciated. Thank you all for being such a blessing to so many!
-
August 2022 by Jim Halpert
Great ice cream and quick service. My friend and I both got a cone and both of our cones got soggy and werid really quick. It was like eating sweet-ish cardboard. And it drips from the bottom of it and creates and horrible sticky mess. So I suggest not getting the cone.
-
August 2022 by Lucas Ashby
Just an average ice cream spot, the choices are good but the ice cream wasn't nearly as good as Coldstone, Braums, or most likely any other good ice cream place nearby
-
August 2022 by Jess
No walffle cones and the workers seem to hate there job but the ice cream was good and gave us a nice amount.
-
July 2022 by Emily Daniels
The ice cream was super melted :( we used to love this place and came back after a few years, but we won’t be back.
