-
May 2024 by Myles Borich
I love overtime cards. There's always good energy at OTC
-
May 2024 by Cody Jacobson
The most friendly people working the shop. Prices are very cheap for what you’re buying. Has lost of variety from Baseball, Football, Basketball, Pokémon, Star Wars, hockey, WWE, and soccer. They also have lots of singles available.
*attached are some hits that I’ve recently got from them.
-
May 2024 by Samuel R
Ripped me off. Sell your cards on eBay
-
May 2024 by Michael Orton
My favorite card shop in the SLC area. Chris has gone out of his way to help me get good soccer card product. They also have good deals on Pokemon cards. I have also used their PSA grading submission service multiple times and have been happy with it. Highly recommend Overtime for your trading card and memorabilia needs.
-
May 2024 by GREG SOUTHERN
Great card shop. They have a great selection of all different cards, employees are friendly and helpful.
-
May 2024 by Chauncey Liston
Chris and Tanner were absolutely spectacular. If you want the feel of an old-school card shop, with new school selection, go here. They took the time to have a conversation about my collection and went into the back to find some of the weird and obscure players from my childhood. Wish I could give them 6 stars. Solid wax inventory and more singles than I could process in almost 2 hours in the shop.
-
April 2024 by Ace Timoteo
Terrible customer service I took in a Pokemon collection that I've had that I personally bought at Target and Walmart and he said that because one of the Pokemon cards that I had was fake he wouldn't look at any of my collection because it's not good business sense to by a collection that had one fake card in it so he said he couldn't buy any of my cards. I asked him well if you can tell that they're fake then you can tell the real ones if you know which ones are fake then you obviously know which ones are real he's like yeah but it doesn't make it's not a good business decision to buy real ones because you had a fake one it didn't really make any sense to me and he was really not trying to explain or talk to me or help me in any way so I'm actually kind of glad that I didn't do business with these people because they're just not very nice
-
April 2024 by J Spencer
Take me back to 1989 please! This place is a lot of fun, love that they are making a go at it and I try to stop in when I'm in the area.
-
April 2024 by Jafey A.
Walking into this place, I truly wanted to love it, it looks ideal but after 5 minutes I was ready to leave. I don't understand how anything is organized so our quest for Jazz cards was short lived and the pricing on packs and boxes is too high, even for a hobby shop.
-
March 2024 by Zoë H.
I absolutely cannot recommend Overtime enough. I come in almost weekly with my husband searching for new basketball cards for my PC, and every single time every employee is beyond friendly, helpful, and engaging. As a woman it's hard to find people in the hobby that treat me kindly, but the guys at this place always ask me questions, show me new cards they know I might like, and are more than willing to help me find cards I'm interested in. Tanner and Chris in particular always go above and beyond to make everyone feel welcome. I love that it feels like everyone that works here genuinely enjoys the hobby, isn't just out for the money, but love collecting and sports. Overall, go to Overtime if you're looking for a fun vibe, great people, and good prices!
-
March 2024 by Alesha Wood
Pulled some nice cards. The staff was nice and very helpful. Most definitely recommend this card shop for your card buying experiences!
-
March 2024 by Dastin
Very very nice people, we pulled great cards out of the pro set metals. This was the best place to spend my birthday with my family.
-
March 2024 by Dominiquee Roberts
Great selection on singles and wax crazy good pricing exactly how I remember hobby shops as a kid they absolutely nail it! Customer service is always A+ and they handle grading it’s a one stop shop check them out!
-
March 2024 by Zoë
absolutely awesome card shop- my husband and i come in here at least once a week to take a look through their basketball bargain bins and i’ve found some of my favorite PC cards for incredible prices. everyone who works there is super friendly and helpful- i love the vibe here and the turnover is great, there’s always new stuff to look at!
-
March 2024 by Erik Neilson
Really good shop.
Great selection.
Nice to be able to buy hobby and elite packs local.
They knew their inventory and had great customer service.
Interesting location.
Had to park on the street. Parking was limited.
