-
September 2024 by rachel mindermann
Your New York Mills one is very poor you can’t order online. It says it cannot connect to the New York Mills store. When you call nobody answers I’ve tried for a month off anon to order pizza and it just you can’t do it. You need to do something with the store.
-
August 2024 by Secrets Jordan
Constantly getting outdated food and drinks from here. Why am I finding juice outdated last month? Why am I getting pizza 2-3 hours past time? Go through your food and drinks..
-
July 2024 by terry brendel
The employee on 6/23/24 the employee on duty at 9:30 was amazing went above and beyond super nice helpful give that boy a raise
-
July 2024 by Olivia Smith
Horrible costumer service! Tried ordering a pizza and after trying to order threw the app and there stupid phone automated thing after about 30 mins finally got connected to a real human and not once but twice he hung up on me when trying to place a pizza order! Never said anything but Casey New York Mills (very rudely) and then hangs up after I talk! So very rude just trying to have a fun pizza and movies with the family with out having to drive very far to get the pizza! Incredibly disappointment!
-
March 2024 by Tony Mitch
Stopped to fill up & get some snacks! Place was clean and the staff was very friendly! Easy location to get in and out of.
-
December 2023 by Ole Bath
They have the best pizza ? that I have ever had. Their prices aren't too bad either.
-
October 2023 by Levi Bruce
Probably the worst ran gas station I’ve seen. I just called an order for pickup at 5:45 I was then told it would be 25 minutes. I show up late at 630 and they said they didn’t even start it. Meanwhile half of the store employees are ripping vapes and smokes out front. Greasy spot (update) I got told 20 more minutesI waited an additional 25 minutes just to be told that it’s made but they forgot to put it in the oven. I don’t understand how this level of bedlam could happen. In summary I ordered at 545 and now it’s 724 and I finally have my pizza. This is attrocious.
-
August 2023 by Jason Covey
Best pizza around love it
-
June 2023 by Tom Garton
Stopped in for breakfast pizza and a soda. Pizza probably would have been ok if the cashier didn't grab the pizza with her bare hands after taking money and who knows what else, to move the pizza over so she could scan the bar code on the sleeve, probably not the best place to put the bar code.Can only assume the person walking around, talking on her phone, and then talking over customers to the cashier, dressed in a very revealing short, short mini skirt, so short things were extremely close to showing, was the manager, not professional in any way.Not risking going back to have this experience again.
-
March 2023 by Rylan Kysar
We stopped for a fountain pop around 9:30 we were walking up to the door and the guy that was working locked it when we were about to grab the handle. We knocked on the door and he would not open the door he walked behind the counter and he started watching a video or something on his phone. This was not a great expirence and we will be taking our business elsewhere.
-
December 2022 by Kaden Ohlrogge
They didn't have enough money to Exchange for $100 and 2 pizza and milk so Duck y'
-
November 2022 by Jenna Pogreba
Stopped around 10am to have breakfast pizza. I didn’t see any so I grabbed a pepperoni that looked a bit dried out (but I was hungry or I wouldn’t have stopped). I asked them about it at the register and she told me they had just thrown out the breakfast pizza since it was passed it’s time and apologized. I ended up tossing the slice I bought because I couldn’t eat it it was so dry. Also when I was leaving there were two gals outside at the corner of the building smoking and cussing/swearing about their shifts and I’m just assuming they were employees. It was very unpleasant.
-
November 2022 by Jenna Bain
Stopped around 10am to have breakfast pizza. I didn’t see any so I grabbed a pepperoni that looked a bit dried out (but I was hungry or I wouldn’t have stopped). I asked them about it at the register and she told me they had just thrown out the breakfast pizza since it was passed it’s time and apologized. I ended up tossing the slice I bought because I couldn’t eat it it was so dry. Also when I was leaving there were two gals outside at the corner of the building smoking and cussing/swearing about their shifts and I’m just assuming they were employees. It was very unpleasant.
-
October 2022 by Roger Mattson
Stopped in to use the bathroom and grab a drink during my long drive. The Mountain Dew was listed at 2/$3.75 and i went to the cashier who rang me up and she charged me full price for them and refused to change the amount to the posted price. I left without, I will gladly take my business elsewhere.
-
October 2022 by Thelma Pirtle
They never have ice tes we stop all the time and yet to get tea. They just say they don't know who makes it. All the other Casey's gave tea you would think they would have some. Not friendly at all.
